01.03
Define the five numbers you will run on
Write exact definitions and formulas for leads, speed to lead, contact rate, appointments held and GCI per lead source, and know where to pull each one in HighLevel and Follow Up Boss.
Video walkthrough
- Why 'leads' means three different things on most teams
- The five headline numbers and the supporting rates behind them
- Where each lives: Follow Up Boss reports, HighLevel dashboards and pipelines
- GCI per lead source: putting commission on the opportunity or the deal
- Weekly vs monthly: which numbers you look at when
What you're building
A metrics sheet with five headline numbers and their supporting rates, each with one written definition, one formula and one place it comes from. Everyone on your team uses the same definitions, and your weekly scorecard (chapter 4) is built from them.
| Metric | Definition | Formula | Cadence |
|---|---|---|---|
| New leads | People who raised their hand for real estate help in the window, from any source | Count of contacts created in the window, excluding imports of old lists, agents, vendors and duplicates | Weekly |
| Speed to lead | How fast a human first reaches out | Median minutes from lead created to first personal call or 1:1 text (automated messages excluded) | Weekly |
| Contact rate | Share of new leads you actually had a conversation with | Leads with a two-way conversation ÷ new leads | Weekly |
| Attempts per lead | How hard you try before stopping | Personal calls + texts + emails in the first 10 days ÷ new leads | Weekly |
| Appointment rate | Conversations that become meetings | Appointments set ÷ leads contacted | Weekly |
| Appointments held | Meetings that actually happened | Count of appointments with outcome held / showed | Weekly |
| Show rate | Booked meetings that happen | Appointments held ÷ appointments set | Weekly |
| Sign rate (conversion) | Meetings that become clients | Signed agreements ÷ appointments held | Monthly |
| GCI per lead source | Commission earned from each source | Sum of gross commission on closed transactions, grouped by original lead source | Monthly / quarterly |
| GCI per lead | What a lead from a source is worth | GCI from source ÷ new leads from source (same cohort window) | Quarterly |
Why it matters
Most disagreements about 'how we are doing' are definition fights. Is a Zillow lead who never answered a lead? Does a showing count as an appointment? Write the answer once. Then numbers become comparable week to week and agent to agent, and the constraint finder in chapter 1 gets trustworthy inputs.
GCI per lead source is the number that ends arguments about spend. A source with fewer leads can be worth more if it closes; you only see that when commission is tied back to the source.
What you need
- Your audit worksheet from chapter 2 (especially sources and stages).
- A place to record commission per closed transaction: Follow Up Boss Deals, a HighLevel opportunity value or custom field, or your back-office spreadsheet.
- The metrics scorecard CSV below.
Time and cost
- Time
- 40 minutes to define; 15 to 30 minutes a week to pull
- Cost
- $0
Step by step
Write your definitions decisions
Fill in the definitions template below. The decisions that most often differ between teams: what counts as a lead (exclude agents, vendors and duplicates), whether a showing counts as an appointment (this Playbook says consultations and first showings count; repeat showings do not), and what counts as a two-way conversation (a reply by text or email or an answered call; auto-replies and STOP replies do not).
Check: Your definitions doc answers each of the five questions in the template with one sentence.
Follow Up Boss: pull leads, speed, attempts and response rate
Reporting > Lead Sources (and Reporting > Agent activity per agent) give New Leads, Avg. Speed to Action and to first call/text/email, Avg. Contact Attempts, % of Leads Responding, Leads Not Acted On, Appointments, Deals Closed, Deal Commission and Conversion Rate by source. Set Lead Type and Time Frame the same way every time and use Export Report for your sheet.
Check: You have last month's numbers for every source in one export.
Follow Up Boss: pull appointments and GCI
Reporting > Appointments filters by time frame, user, type and outcome; count outcome Held for appointments held and divide by all appointments for show rate (outcomes are set up in Admin > Appointments). For GCI, create a Deal for every transaction (Deals tab or the lead profile) with price and commission. The Lead Sources report then shows Deal Commission per source.
Check: Every closing in the window has a deal with commission, and the Lead Sources report shows commission per source.
HighLevel: pull leads, contact rate and appointments
- New leads: opportunities in the lead pipeline with Created On in the window (every lead gets an opportunity in Part 03, chapter 3).
- Contact rate: of those, how many reached the Contacted stage or later (filter by stage, or count in the board).
- Appointments: Reporting > Appointment Report shows counts by status (booked, confirmed, cancelled and more). Count Showed for appointments held.
- Speed to lead and attempts: HighLevel's help center does not document a per-lead speed report, so use the 20-lead sample in Part 03, chapter 9.
Check: You have new leads, contacted and appointments held for last month from HighLevel.
HighLevel: put GCI on the opportunity and read it by source
When a transaction closes, set the opportunity's value to the GCI (not the sale price) and mark it Won. Add the Lead Source Report widget to a dashboard: per source it shows total leads, open, won, lost and abandoned, with values. Won value per source is your GCI per lead source.
Check: The Lead Source Report shows a won value for at least one source that matches your closed GCI.
What success looks like
- One written definition and formula per metric, shared with the team.
- Each metric has a named place it is pulled from in your CRM.
- Last month's five headline numbers filled in the scorecard.
Copyable templates
# Our metric definitions (decided {date})
1. A **lead** is: a person who asked for real estate help through {sources}. Not leads: agents, vendors, job seekers, duplicates, imported old lists.
2. **First personal touch** is: a call or 1:1 text by a person. Automated texts and emails do not count.
3. A **two-way conversation** is: a reply by text or email, or an answered call. Auto-replies and opt-out replies do not count.
4. An **appointment** is: a buyer or listing consultation, or a first showing, with a date and time. Repeat showings do not count.
5. **GCI** is recorded on: {Follow Up Boss Deal commission / HighLevel opportunity value / GCI custom field}, entered by {owner} within {2} days of closing.Try it
- New leads→toContacted÷ leads
- Contacted→toAppointments set÷ contacted
- Appointments set→toAppointments held÷ set
- Appointments held→toSigned÷ held
- Signed→toGCI by sourceclosings
How to test it
- Pick one source and one month. Compute contact rate by hand from 10 leads and compare with the report. Investigate any gap over 10 points.
- Check one closing: its commission appears under the right source in the report.
- Ask a teammate to pull one metric using only your definitions doc. Their number should match yours.
Troubleshooting
Lead counts jump when we import a list.
Exclude imports in the definition, and filter them out (Follow Up Boss Lead Type: web; HighLevel: use opportunities created by the routing workflow, or tag imports).
GCI by source looks wrong because source was overwritten.
Source should be the original way the lead arrived. Follow Up Boss allows editing source manually; agree that nobody changes it after creation.
Show rate looks perfect because nobody marks no-shows.
Outcomes must be marked the same day (Part 03, chapter 8). Until then, treat show rate as unknown.
Advanced technical details
Optional. You can follow every step above without these.
Technical detailsCohorts vs activity windows
Two ways to count: by activity window (everything that happened this month) or by cohort (what happened to leads created this month, however long it takes). Activity windows are easy and fine for weekly speed and attempts. Rates further down the funnel (sign rate, GCI per lead) should be cohort-based, because a lead from March may close in August. Note which one each scorecard column uses.
Technical detailsWhat could not be verified
HighLevel's Appointment Report status names in your account, and whether your plan includes Call Reporting (documented as an Agency Pro plan feature). Check both before relying on them.
Sources
Written from the best available information. One or more steps could not be confirmed; see the notes in the chapter. Last checked 2026-10-20.
- Speed to lead & lead source reportFollow Up Boss Help Center · read 2026-10-20
- Agent activity reportFollow Up Boss Help Center · read 2026-10-20
- Appointment ReportFollow Up Boss Help Center · read 2026-10-20
- Deals OverviewFollow Up Boss Help Center · read 2026-10-20
- Lead Source Report: see leads, status, and value by sourceHighLevel Help Center · read 2026-10-20
- Appointment ReportHighLevel Help Center · read 2026-10-20
- How to Filter OpportunitiesHighLevel Help Center · read 2026-10-20
- Call ReportingHighLevel Help Center · read 2026-10-20